Three national cloud security schemes in the EU
The EU still has no single binding cloud certification (the EUCS scheme under the Cybersecurity Act is not yet adopted), so public bodies and regulated sectors rely on national schemes. The three most often required in procurement are France's SecNumCloud, Germany's C5 and Spain's ENS. They differ in kind, not just in strictness.
| SecNumCloud (France) | C5 (Germany) | ENS (Spain) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Owner | ANSSI | BSI | CCN under Royal Decree 311/2022 |
| Nature | State qualification of a specific offering | Auditor attestation (ISAE 3000 style), Type 1 or Type 2 | Certification by accredited bodies, levels Básica, Media, Alta |
| Sovereignty | Version 3.2 requires immunity from non-EU law, limiting non-EU ownership | Transparency criteria on data location and jurisdiction, no ownership rule | No ownership rule |
| Where required | French state "cloud au centre" doctrine for sensitive data | German federal bodies, healthcare (cloud use under section 393 SGB V) | Spanish public sector and its suppliers |
Reading a qualification
SecNumCloud qualifies an offering, not a company. A provider can have one qualified private cloud alongside non-qualified public services, so procurement documents should name the qualified service. ANSSI publishes the qualified offerings in its catalogue of qualified products and services; qualification runs for three years with annual surveillance audits. The 3.2 version added the requirement that the provider and its offering be protected from extra-EU laws, which is why hyperscaler offerings in France are delivered through French-controlled joint ventures such as S3NS (Thales and Google Cloud) and Bleu (Orange and Capgemini, with Microsoft technology).
C5 is not a pass/fail certificate: the auditor's report lists the criteria and any deviations, and a Type 2 report covers operating effectiveness over a period. Buyers should ask for the report itself. ENS certificates state the category (Básica, Media, Alta) and the scope of systems covered, and the CCN maintains a public register of certified entities.
The sample shows the scheme and offering as each provider names it on its own site. The count of providers is an estimate.