R2 and e-Stewards: the two electronics recycling standards
Retired laptops, servers, phones and the batteries inside them carry two risks for the organisation that discards them: data that has not been destroyed, and hazardous materials that end up in the wrong place. Corporate IT asset disposition (ITAD) contracts and many public tenders therefore require a recycler certified to R2 or e-Stewards, the two accredited certification standards for the electronics recycling industry.
| R2v3 | e-Stewards | |
|---|---|---|
| Owner | SERI (Sustainable Electronics Recycling International) | Basel Action Network (BAN) |
| Structure | Core requirements plus process requirements (appendices) for data sanitisation, test and repair, materials recovery and others | Single standard incorporating ISO 14001 and ISO 45001 requirements |
| Exports | Allowed to legally importing countries under conditions | Prohibits export of hazardous electronic waste from developed to developing countries, in line with the Basel Ban Amendment |
| Audit | Accredited certification bodies | Accredited certification bodies, with tracking devices used in BAN's export investigations |
Batteries are a separate problem
Lithium-ion batteries cause a growing share of fires at recycling facilities and in collection trucks. In the United States, batteries are managed under the EPA universal waste rules (40 CFR Part 273), and the EPA has been developing specific universal waste standards for lithium batteries. A certified electronics recycler may remove batteries but send them to a separate battery recycler, so buyers should ask where batteries go and whether that downstream processor is named in the recycler's downstream due diligence.
What to check
- The certificate covers the specific facility that will handle the material; certifications are site by site.
- For data-bearing devices, the R2v3 data sanitisation appendix or e-Stewards data security requirements, and often NAID AAA certification.
- Downstream vendors for batteries, CRT glass, circuit boards and plastics.
- Whether refurbished devices are resold, and how revenue sharing is calculated.
The sample is taken from the e-Stewards list of certified processors; locations and services are those listed for each processor. The count is an estimate covering both standards.